I n this study we designed to test the remarkable repayment performance of akhuwat in pakistan. Apr 28, 2008 group lending, repayment incentives and social collateral. This type of scheme, especially in the guise of the grameen bank in bangladesh, has received increasing attention. We take into account the external ties of group borrowers, i. Group lending, repayment incentives and social collateral, journal of. Implicationsofthecrisisinindianmicrofinancenov2010. In this paper, we investigate the impact on repayment rates of lending to groups which are made jointly liable for repayment.
Grameen bank apart, the performance of group lending has been very mixed. Thus, to improve the group loan repayment performance. Wydick 1999 in his study in guatemala recorded that social cohesion and the strong social ties have rather negative than positive impact on repayment rates. Age, loan size, and duration showed a significant negative impact on the repayment rate but social ties and. Group lending i consider a group composed of two ex ante identical borrowers referred to as borrowers 1 and 2, respectively. External social ties and loan repayment of group lending. Groups have served a crucial social purpose in the func. Improving loan repayment through positive incentives in uganda researchers evaluated the effect of a simple text message reminders and b financial incentives on borrowers loan repayment. Economic theorists have been particularly interested in group lending, and nearly all of the economic work on microfinance focuses on the incentives induced by joint liability in group lending contracts, building on lending models pioneered by. Is group lending a good enforcement scheme for achieving high. Repayment incentives and insurance in village economies ashok s. I find that stronger social connections of the group lead to improved expost repayment and savings behavior by the clients. Without legal contractual obligations established to push members to adhere to a stipulated timeframe and interest rates many group members fail to pay back under the lenders lending conditions.
Financial mechanisms that could facilitate asset buildup, protect against risks, and sustain. Pdf defining social collateral in microfinance group lending. Abstract in this paper, we investigate the impact on repayment rates of lending to groups which are made jointly liable for repayment. While such lending has bene tted millions of borrowers, major lending insti tutions have acknowledged their limited impact among the very poor and have recently favored individual contracts. Group lending and individual lending with strategic default group lending advantages of group lending in microfinance repayment incentives and the. Group lending, repayment incentives and social collateral timothy besley a, stephen coate b, woodrow wilson school, princeton university, princeton, nj 0854410, usa b wharton school, university of. In this backdrop, social collateral is popularized through the group lending programs to address the credit market problems. To secure future access, members are obliged to monitor each other. The negative effect arises when the whole group defaults, even when some members would have repaid under individual lending. Microfinance institutions mfis grant loans backed by social collateral to poor entrepreneurs. Group lending, repayment incentives and social collateral.
The role of groups and credit cooperatives in rural lending, policy research working paper series 284, the world bank. Group liability is often portrayed as the key innovation that led to the explosion of the microcredit movement, which started with the grameen bank in the 1970s and continues on today with hundreds. Determinants of mfis group loan repayment performance. Google scholar daleyharris, sam 2003, the state of the. Google scholar daleyharris, sam 2003, the state of the microcredit summit campaign2003. Group lending with joint liability is seen as an effective instrument to circumvent information asymmetries because it incentivizes group members to use their social ties to screen, monitor, and enforce loan repayment on their peers. Under an individual lending contract, all the borrower has to fear, if he defaults, is the penalties that the bank can impose on him. We also derive predictions for how loan repayment performance changes as a function of changes in the level of endogenous social capital. The challenges of agricultural lending rural finance and.
Many believe that a key innovation by the grameen bank is to encourage borrowers to help each other in. Group lending, repayment incentives and social collateral, journal of development economics, 461, pp. Pdf microfinance institutions mfis grant loans backed by social collateral to poor. However, in groupbased lending, it is not easy to distinguish. Collective action, social capital and group lending 151 collective action, social capital and group lending f or lowincome households with meager assets, financial services that could potentially augment their income are of extreme importance. The findings of empirical studies concerning the determinants of repayment rates in group lending in respect to social capital indicators are controversial. University of groningen adverse selection and moral hazard. In theory, at least, lending was based on joint liabilityor the idea that a second member of the group could not get a loan until the first paid back, thereby creating an incentive for peer monitoring as first. Pdf besley coate group lending repayment incentives and. The lending philosophy of mfis is based on the grameen bank model in which. In this paper we extend the besley and coate 1995 model by analyzing how the repayment game is altered when loans within a group are made sequentially instead of simultaneously. Tax incentives gst guide on export incentives nonfood incentives and rewards in the classroom incentives in bitcoin mining sector enterprise risk management from incentives to controls harmful. Since friends may be softer and more forgiving on each other, it is not necessarily true that stronger social ties lead to higher repayment rates. Microfinance institutions mfis grant loans backed by social collateral to poor.
Thus if social penalties are severe enough, group lending will result in a higher repayment rate than individual lending. The borrowers in a group are made liable for each others repayment. Age, loan size, and duration showed a significant negative impact on the repayment rate but social ties and professional training of the borrower have expected positive impact on the repayment performance. Hence, it has received a lot of attention from policy makers as well as. When evaluating the role social capital plays in group lending, these networks and the internal and external ties they entail, need to be mapped. Social capital and the repayment of microfinance group lending. A case of dedebit credit and saving institution, mekelle. Woodrow wilson school, princeton university, princeton.
Solidarity group lending and global games 3 exclusion of nonpaying members from continued access to credit. Besley and coate 1995 show that the wrath of other group members incurred by the defaulter under group lending may constitute a powerful incentive device in tightly knit communities. Tax incentives gst guide on export incentives nonfood incentives and rewards in the classroom incentives in bitcoin mining sector enterprise risk management from incentives to controls harmful incentives. Designing enforcement in an efficient way is another challenge to control loan loss risk in agricultural lending. Although microfinance institutions across the world are moving from group lending towards individual lending, this strategic shift is not substantiated by sufficient empirical evidence on the impact of both. A second feature of our analysis is an attempt to capture the idea that group lending may be able to harness social collateral. The social collateral systems or ties constitutes a powerful device to reinforce repayment among group members.
We set up and analyze the repayment game which group lending gives rise to. While theoretical models have described the potential of group lending, little empirical evidence has been found to understand if and how group lending actually. Collective action, social capital and group lending. Repayment incentives and the distribution of gains from group. Economic theorists have been particularly interested in group lending, and nearly all of the economic work on microfinance focuses.
The literature on microfinance lacks a rigid framework for analyzing the consequences of using social collateral for borrowing behavior and repayment. The case of fisheries subsidies repayment incentives and the distribution of gains from group lending incentives selection and teacher performance evidence from impact incentives in bitcoin. Factors influencing loan repayment performance among group borrowers in bungoma west district, bungoma county. Each invests this in a project whose returns are independent. The role of groups and credit cooperatives in rural lending, world bank research observer, world bank group, vol. Also, legal procedures to use collateral are often cumbersome and costly. We also derive predictions for how loan repayment performance changes as a function of.
In theory, at least, lending was based on joint liabilityor the idea that a second member of the group could not get a loan until the first paid back, thereby creating an incentive for peer monitoring as first described by stiglitz in 1990. Group lending, joint liability, and social capital columbia. Group lending, repayment incentives and social collateral core. The lending philosophy of mfis is based on the grameen bank model in which social groups form the collateral for receiving a loan. This type of scheme, especially in the guise of the grameen bank in bangladesh. However, in group based lending, it is not easy to distinguish individual liability from group liability, when members belonging in a group reflect the average attributes of all members of that group.
The incentive to repay the loan is based on peer pressure, if one group member defaults, the other group members make up the payment amount. Under individual lending, default would occur if a borrower had a return below. Coate 1995, group lending, repayment incentives and social collateral. Group loans with joint liability have been a distinguishing feature of many micro nance programs. Group lending and individual lending with strategic default group lending advantages of group lending in microfinance repayment incentives and the distribution of gains from group lending group lending, repayment incentives and social collateral besley coate group lending repayment incentives and social collateral do predatory lending laws. Besley coate group lending repayment incentives and social collateral jde. Sorry, we are unable to provide the full text but you may find it at the following locations. The positive effect is that successful group members may have an incentive to repay the loans of group members whose projects have yielded insufficient return to make repayment worthwhile. The rst term is the probability that one borrower will have a return above. A lending mechanism which allows a group of individuals often called a solidarity group to provide collateral or loan guarantee through a group repayment pledge.
Improving loan repayment through positive incentives in. Coate, group lending, repayment incentives and social collateral, journal of. To secure future access, members are obliged to monitor each. Defining social collateral in microfinance group lending.
Is group lending a good enforcement scheme for achieving. Peermonitoring, screening, peerpressure, social ties, loan officer visit to the group, and other sources of credit were found to have statistically significant effect on the group loan repayment performance. Group lending, repayment incentives and social collateral timothy besley a, stephen coate b, woodrow wilson school, princeton university, princeton, nj 0854410, usa b wharton school, university of pennsylvania, philadelphia, pa 191046372, usa received september 1992. Microfinance through group lending is acting as a screening device. The impact of monitoring activities and social ties of group leaders on the repayment performance of group. At the beginning of the period, the group is granted a loan of two units of capital, one for each borrower. Traditional collateral, however, is rarely available from small farmers. The literature on microfinance lacks a rigid framework for.
Rai williams college and tomas sjostrom pennsylvania state university first version received november 2000. Microfinance group lending with joint liability allows assetpoor individuals to replace physical collateral by social collateral. Collective action, social capital and group lending 151 collective action, social capital and group lending f or lowincome households with meager assets. Factors influencing loan repayment performance among. Group size and social ties in microfinance institutions. Factors influencing mfis group loan repayment performance. A case study of pro mujer mexico, working papers ceb 15023, ulb. The stronger impact on consumption and business creation in grouplending villages, after several loan cycles, may indicate that group loans are more effective at increasing the permanent income of. These methods had similarly positive effects, which suggests that the text message reminders may be a more costeffective intervention. In this paper we extend the besley and coate 1995 model by. Under group lending, he may also incur the wrath of other group members. Since friends may be softer and more forgiving on each other, it is not necessarily. Social capital, social collateral, group lending, repayment. Repayment incentives and the distribution of gains from group lending jeanmarie balandy rohini somanathanz zaki wahhaj x november 12, 2010 abstract group loans with joint liability have been a.
715 926 810 824 1406 1089 1254 1311 864 384 627 1506 505 556 1535 104 1099 560 1022 1563 117 196 772 1415 554 713 1472 394 1110 1065 127